NavList:
A Community Devoted to the Preservation and Practice of Celestial Navigation and Other Methods of Traditional Wayfinding
From: Ed Popko
Date: 2019 Feb 2, 14:01 -0800
Ron,
Thanks for looking at it.
I made a huge cut/paste error in the Cleared LD column. The original post was hugely wrong, not even remotely close. Surprising I did not see this huge error jump out before posting. The values in the LUNARS SUMMARY are correct. The interpolations still stand, the Cleared LDs listed there were correct.
BTW, if you need lunars test cases, I have several text files I can send you which offers a mix of personal cases and ones taken from classic 19th century text book examples. I use them to check my calculator programs as I have programed four different lunars algorithms.
LUNARS SUMMARY
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Near Limb Cleared
Sight GMT LD [1] LD [2] Error [2] Comment
-----------------------------------------------------------------
1. 11:06:55 24° 50.1' 25° 36.3' -1.1' <-- rejected
2. 11:09:27 24° 51.1' 25° 36.8' 0.6'
3. 11.11:23 24° 49.6' 25° 34.9' -0.4'
4. 11:13:43 24° 48.7' 25° 33.6' -0.6'
5. 11:14:31 24° 48.9' 25° 33.6' -0.2'
6. 11:16:35 24° 48.4' 25° 32.7' -0.1' LD same as 7
7. 11:17:13 24° 48.4' 25° 32.6' 0.1' LD same as 6
8. 11:18:15 24° 47.8' 25° 31.8' -0.2' LD same as 9
9. 11:19:16 24° 47.8' 25° 31.6' 0.1' LD same as 8
10. 11:20:09 24° 47.5' 25° 31.1' 0.0' <-- fluke
-----------------------------------------------------------------
[1] observed
[2] reduced using Reed's Lunars Calclator
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
LUNARS TIME BRACKET
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Predicted Cleared Lunars
GMT Geocentric Lunar Computed Computed vs
Sight Time Lunar Distance Distance Time Actual GMT Comment
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Almanac 11:00:00 25° 40.8'
1. 11:06:55 25° 36.3' 11:09:21 2Min 26sec fast worst case
6. 11:16:35 25° 32.7' 11:16:49 14sec fast
8. 11:18:15 25° 31.8' 11:18:41 2sec fast a good one
10. 11:20:09 25° 31.1' 11:20:08 1sec slow a fluke
Almanac 12:00:00 25° 11.9'
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* from web Predicted Geocentric Lunar Distances app