NavList:
A Community Devoted to the Preservation and Practice of Celestial Navigation and Other Methods of Traditional Wayfinding
Re: List Status: we've moved successfully...
From: Frank Reed CT
Date: 2006 May 14, 18:46 -0500
"1. I still don't understand whether
we are going to lose our Nav-L
archives on the web?
I think this will be a major disaster."
I'll be somewhat brief here. The present archive for the list is maintained
by "some guy". It is not an official archive. Neither the list "owner" nor
any of the active list participants have any control over this archive. It can
be deleted on a moment's notice if the guy who runs it decides he doesn't
want to bother with it anymore (or if his computer dies). I'm not saying that
there is any likelihood that this will happen --merely pointing out that it is
completely out of our control. The present list archive on i-DEADLINK-com that
you're talking about is merely an e-mail address subscribed to the list by the
owner of that site because it interests him. A service on his computer takes
each e-mail, strips out anything formatted like an e-mail address from the
messages (nice feature), and dumps it into his archives. It's very convenient,
and I think it's nice that he has this set up. If we ask him, maybe he'll
subscribe an e-mail address to NavList, too. But if he gets d, the list
archive will automatically stop [this happened in March. ten days of
messages to Nav-L are gone from those archives]. Perhaps it would be best if we set
up an acrhive WE can control. Dan Allen has maintained an EXTENSIVE personal
archive which we can easily combine into one grand archive that flows
seamlessly to the present.
By the way, "major disaster"?? Let's not take ourselves too seriously here.
:-)
You also wrote:
"2. As I understand the only reason why we
are forced to move is that nobody wants
to maintain the old list, as a moderator.
(I cannot do this for only one reason: I don't know how.
I am not in good relations with computers in general).
But I am really VERY SORRY for what is happening."
Alex, I have answered a number of messages from you on this topic, and you
have never replied. It is almost as if you have never received those messages.
Hey, wait a minute! Maybe that's it. :-) Alex, are you aware by now that the
present server for Nav-L is dumping messages? That is, messages sent to the
list address are NOT distributing fully to the list. I can point to two in
the past thirty days, and there are undoubtedly more. The most obvious was
titled "Compute Suns position". It's not in the archives. Other people never
received it in their inboxes. THIS IS VERY POOR BEHAVIOR for a listserv.
Additionally, the listserv has crashed --dead, totally unresponsive-- twice in the
past six months. THIS IS ALSO VERY POOR BEHAVIOR for a listserv. And just
before it crashes, the list has regurgitated a bunch of months-old messages (I've
called them "echo posts"). You yourself were placed in the fairly ludicrous
position in early April of responding to a message, asking for resources on
lunars, which had been sent to the list in December of last year (but was
distirbuted by the malfunctioning listserv in April). All of these are excellent
reasons to move the list to a new server. Normal Internet mailing lists do not
have these screwy problems!
As for Dan Hogan, I do not and will not try to speak for him. But I do
believe that many list members imagine that he has powers as list "owner" that he
does not have. It is mostly work with very little power. He has said that
he's tired of the work. A list "owner" owns nothing. A list owner has no "magic
wand" capable of controlling discussions (on unmoderated lists). It's just a
job, and you can thank Dan H for doing it, but if he is unable to resolve the
technical problems (and that does appear to be the case), then what else
would you do?
Finally, you said that you are "VERY SORRY for what is happening" --which I
find quite remarkable. I will say one thing here in closing that I hope will
help you. A "list" like this one is a GROUP OF PEOPLE. It is not a server on
a machine. You are communicating with the same group of people as before. You
are currently the second most prolific poster on NavList. And of course you
are --the topics interest you, the people are familiar, so you reply. THAT is
the list --this group of people talking about navigation. So what do you
have to be sorry about? You're chatting about a topic you enjoy with the same
group of people whom you have come to know. The only real difference is that you
send your messages to a different e-mail address. I can understand loyalty,
even irrational loyalty, when it is directed towards a human being. But who
in the world feels loyalty to an e-mail address?! Honestly, will you miss the
name 'webkahuna' in your messages? We're talking about MIGRATING a list
(list=group of people) from one server to another. What's there to be sorry about?
It's a tough process when it has to be done, but we've done it. The list has
migrated successfully. So relax and enjoy yourself! :-) Talk about
navigation... :-)
-FER
42.0N 87.7W, or 41.4N 72.1W.
www.HistoricalAtlas.com/lunars
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
To post to this group, send email to NavList@fer3.com
To , send email to NavList-@fer3.com
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
From: Frank Reed CT
Date: 2006 May 14, 18:46 -0500
"1. I still don't understand whether
we are going to lose our Nav-L
archives on the web?
I think this will be a major disaster."
I'll be somewhat brief here. The present archive for the list is maintained
by "some guy". It is not an official archive. Neither the list "owner" nor
any of the active list participants have any control over this archive. It can
be deleted on a moment's notice if the guy who runs it decides he doesn't
want to bother with it anymore (or if his computer dies). I'm not saying that
there is any likelihood that this will happen --merely pointing out that it is
completely out of our control. The present list archive on i-DEADLINK-com that
you're talking about is merely an e-mail address subscribed to the list by the
owner of that site because it interests him. A service on his computer takes
each e-mail, strips out anything formatted like an e-mail address from the
messages (nice feature), and dumps it into his archives. It's very convenient,
and I think it's nice that he has this set up. If we ask him, maybe he'll
subscribe an e-mail address to NavList, too. But if he gets d, the list
archive will automatically stop [this happened in March. ten days of
messages to Nav-L are gone from those archives]. Perhaps it would be best if we set
up an acrhive WE can control. Dan Allen has maintained an EXTENSIVE personal
archive which we can easily combine into one grand archive that flows
seamlessly to the present.
By the way, "major disaster"?? Let's not take ourselves too seriously here.
:-)
You also wrote:
"2. As I understand the only reason why we
are forced to move is that nobody wants
to maintain the old list, as a moderator.
(I cannot do this for only one reason: I don't know how.
I am not in good relations with computers in general).
But I am really VERY SORRY for what is happening."
Alex, I have answered a number of messages from you on this topic, and you
have never replied. It is almost as if you have never received those messages.
Hey, wait a minute! Maybe that's it. :-) Alex, are you aware by now that the
present server for Nav-L is dumping messages? That is, messages sent to the
list address are NOT distributing fully to the list. I can point to two in
the past thirty days, and there are undoubtedly more. The most obvious was
titled "Compute Suns position". It's not in the archives. Other people never
received it in their inboxes. THIS IS VERY POOR BEHAVIOR for a listserv.
Additionally, the listserv has crashed --dead, totally unresponsive-- twice in the
past six months. THIS IS ALSO VERY POOR BEHAVIOR for a listserv. And just
before it crashes, the list has regurgitated a bunch of months-old messages (I've
called them "echo posts"). You yourself were placed in the fairly ludicrous
position in early April of responding to a message, asking for resources on
lunars, which had been sent to the list in December of last year (but was
distirbuted by the malfunctioning listserv in April). All of these are excellent
reasons to move the list to a new server. Normal Internet mailing lists do not
have these screwy problems!
As for Dan Hogan, I do not and will not try to speak for him. But I do
believe that many list members imagine that he has powers as list "owner" that he
does not have. It is mostly work with very little power. He has said that
he's tired of the work. A list "owner" owns nothing. A list owner has no "magic
wand" capable of controlling discussions (on unmoderated lists). It's just a
job, and you can thank Dan H for doing it, but if he is unable to resolve the
technical problems (and that does appear to be the case), then what else
would you do?
Finally, you said that you are "VERY SORRY for what is happening" --which I
find quite remarkable. I will say one thing here in closing that I hope will
help you. A "list" like this one is a GROUP OF PEOPLE. It is not a server on
a machine. You are communicating with the same group of people as before. You
are currently the second most prolific poster on NavList. And of course you
are --the topics interest you, the people are familiar, so you reply. THAT is
the list --this group of people talking about navigation. So what do you
have to be sorry about? You're chatting about a topic you enjoy with the same
group of people whom you have come to know. The only real difference is that you
send your messages to a different e-mail address. I can understand loyalty,
even irrational loyalty, when it is directed towards a human being. But who
in the world feels loyalty to an e-mail address?! Honestly, will you miss the
name 'webkahuna' in your messages? We're talking about MIGRATING a list
(list=group of people) from one server to another. What's there to be sorry about?
It's a tough process when it has to be done, but we've done it. The list has
migrated successfully. So relax and enjoy yourself! :-) Talk about
navigation... :-)
-FER
42.0N 87.7W, or 41.4N 72.1W.
www.HistoricalAtlas.com/lunars
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
To post to this group, send email to NavList@fer3.com
To , send email to NavList-@fer3.com
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---