NavList:
A Community Devoted to the Preservation and Practice of Celestial Navigation and Other Methods of Traditional Wayfinding
From: Frank Reed
Date: 2026 Nov 17, 06:30 -0800
David Pike, you wrote:
"I'm just wondering what it was fed on, because there's a nice artificial horizon there. "
Yes. A real sextant. The original poster admitted that he used A.I. to "clean up" an original photo of a sextant that he is apparently trying to sell. That's an unfortunate abuse of this sort of tech. It's like what people routinely used to called "photoshop-ing", but this is far easier to create and harder for most people to spot. Maybe with a year or two, most A.I. fakes will be undetectable. That's a dangerous but seemingly inescapable future. The era of "photography as evidence of reality" is ending.
I, too, thought there were issues with the screw heads. Skipping the list, I have marked up one of the images pointing out some problems.
By the way, for everyone reading along, I had initially named the images with a prefix "AA-stop" so that I could change them easily today (after the cat was out of the bag). The images in the original post and in the archive are now prefixed "AI-slop", as they should be.
A.I. photo fakes are improving rapidly. The flaws we noticed easily two or three years ago have mostly been suppressed. How long will it be until we can no longer see any differences at all? Six weeks ago, the NYTimes ran a "scrollytext" story asking the question: This Photos Is an A.I. Fake. Can You Tell? It's a good read. The link is to a FREE article. If it asks you to subscribe, just hit 'skip' or 'not now' or whatever escape option it provides, and read...
Frank Reed






