Welcome to the NavList Message Boards.

NavList:

A Community Devoted to the Preservation and Practice of Celestial Navigation and Other Methods of Traditional Wayfinding

Compose Your Message

Message:αβγ
Add Images & Files
    Name or NavList Code:
    Email:
       
    Reply
    Re: Summer reading
    From: Jackson McDonald
    Date: 2016 Aug 31, 16:10 +0000

    Bob, I have access to the 1977 edition and look forward to reading the chapter on sight reduction methods as they have evolved over time.  Thanks for the tip.  Jackson 




    From: NavList@navlist.net <NavList@navlist.net> on behalf of Bob Goethe <NoReply_Goethe@navlist.net>
    Sent: Tuesday, August 30, 2016 14:03
    To: jacksonmcdonald@hotmail.com
    Subject: [NavList] Re: Summer reading
     

    Jackson, thank you for your book recommendations.  I have just requested two of them from my local library.

    I purchased a 1977 edition of Bowditch (actually, volume 1 is 1977 while the "matching" volume 2 was published in 1975) because https://www.starpath.com/resources2/sight_average.pdf by David Burch indicated that a "1977 or earlier" edition would have a better discussion of celestial sight averaging.  I read it through from cover to cover, and found it a delightful journey.

    www.starpath.com
    Averging Celestial Sights, David Burch, Page 1 How to Average Celestial Sights for Optimum Accuracy The beauty of celestial navigation is its transparency, meaning ...

    I have also read the 2002 edition cover to cover, and my sense is that 1) Bowditch editors wanted to get the book down to one volume instead of two, and found that - in the GPS era - an easy step to take was to strip out a lot of the celestial material, and 2) Bowditch 2002 tells you all you need to DO celestial navigation, but does not spend as much time as it used to in telling you WHY you do those things.  The other thing that the 1977 edition has is a (to me, at least) fascinating chapter on sight reduction techniques as they have evolved over time.  That chapter is completely missing from the 2002 edition.

    One of the things I found striking in my 1977 was the dismissal of the noon sight.  "As accurate time became available at sea...the noon sight lost its importance....True, the solution of a meridian altitude is simple and quick, but this is more than offset by the need for determining the time at which to make the observation, the dislike of many mariners for having to make an observation at a predetermined time, the inconvenience sometimes experiened when local apparent noon occurs at a time when other activities conflict with observation, and the possibility of missing the observation because of overcase conditions.  The practice of observing a body when a line of position is desired, and solving those which happen to have a meridian angle of 0° or 180° in the same manner as other observations, is a growing practice that eliminates the need for remembering a separate procedure for bodies on the celestial meridain.   The modern navigator thinks primarily in terms of lines of position, reather than of latitude and longitude observations" (p. 560).

    This perspective, from the last pre-GPS-era Bowditch edition, seems significant to me, as it is based on input from a much larger number of working celestial navigators than exists in the world today.  Oddly enough, most of the celestial nav texts I have reviewed from the 21st century (including Bowditch 2002) suggest that the noon sight is more simple to do than a St. Hilaire line of position, with no appreciation for what the consensus of "modern navigators" was in 1977 regarding simplicity in celestial nav. 

    John Karl's book, Celestial Navigation in the GPS Age, is an exception here.  He seems more in sync with Bowditch 1977, and says regarding "special sights":  "The advantage of having good proficiency in one method might trump the advantages of these additional sights.... Additionally, I think there has been an irrelevant historical carryover on the importance of determining latitude rather than a regular LOP.  After all, a known latitude is just an east-west LOP.  [The real consideratioin is] the LOP crossing angle at noon relative to the morning and afternoon sun lines, used for running fixes" (p. 159).

    Bob

       
    Reply
    Browse Files

    Drop Files

    NavList

    What is NavList?

    NavList is a community devoted to the preservation and practice of celestial navigation and other methods of traditional position-finding. We're a group of navigators, navigation enthusiasts and hobbyists, mathematicians and physicists, and historians interested in all aspects of navigation but primarily those techniques which are non-electronic.

    To post a message, if you are already signed up as a NavList member, start a new discussion or reply to any posted message and use your posting code (this is a simple low-security password assigned when you join). You may also join by posting. Your first on-topic messsage automatically makes you a member, and a posting code will be assigned and emailed to you for future posts.

    Uniquely, the NavList message boards also permit full interaction entirely by email. You can optionally receive individual posts or daily digests by email, and any member can post messages by email (bypassing the web site) by sending to our posting address which is "NavList@NavList.net". This functionality is similar to a traditional Internet mailing list: post by email, read by email, reply by email. Most members will prefer the web interface here for posting and replying to messages.

    NavList is more than an online community... more about that another day.

    © Copyright notice: please note that the rights to all messages and posts in this discussion group are held by their respective authors. No messages or text or images extracted from messages may be reproduced without the explicit consent of the message author. Email me, Frank Reed, if you have any questions.

    Join / Get NavList ID Code

    Name:
    (please, no nicknames or handles)
    Email:
    Do you want to receive all group messages by email?
    Yes No

    A NavList ID Code guarantees your identity in NavList posts and allows faster posting of messages.

    Retrieve a NavList ID Code

    Enter the email address associated with your NavList messages. Your NavList code will be emailed to you immediately.
    Email:

    Email Settings

    NavList ID Code:

    Custom Index

    Subject:
    Author:
    Start date: (yyyymm dd)
    End date: (yyyymm dd)

    Visit this site
    Visit this site
    Visit this site
    Visit this site
    Visit this site
    Visit this site