NavList:
A Community Devoted to the Preservation and Practice of Celestial Navigation and Other Methods of Traditional Wayfinding
From: Geoff Hitchcox
Date: 2023 Oct 14, 03:48 -0700
Hello all, on the 14 Oct 2023 ( Although NZ beat you all by being 13 hours ahead of UTC ;-)
Firstly, I must say that it was very pleasing to see that Paul_H and I agree *exactly* on when the SunLL is occulted and then exposed - by using different methods.
Thanks Paul, I guess that means we need to be slightly suspicious of Stellarium's precision.
Kermit and Paul, I'm confused why you think there would be no difference between a "Standard Atmosphere" and an "Airless model" for predicting when an eclipse occurs or finishes.
I have copied below the raw input data to see if that helps understand that *different* input data, will give *different* outcome.
2023-Oct-14 18:51:10.5 = Last touch of the Moon with the Sun (using Standard Refraction model).
2023-Oct-14 18:51:08.5 = Last touch of the Moon with the Sun (using Airless model).
Location = 28.0° North, 90.0° West, 0 Altitude.
Here is the raw input Data (from JPL Horizons)
Date__(UT)__HR:MN:SC.fff, Azi_(app), Elev_(app), Ang-diam (arc seconds)
2023-Oct-14 18:51:10.500, 205.866672, 50.480288, 1924.170 = SUN (using Standard Refraction model)
2023-Oct-14 18:51:08.500, 205.854740, 50.469536, 1924.170 = SUN (using Airless model).
2023-Oct-14 18:51:10.500, 205.176793, 50.201429, 1828.476 = MOON (using Standard Refraction model)
2023-Oct-14 18:51:08.500, 205.165141, 50.190523, 1828.477 = MOON (using Airless model).
2023-Oct-14 18:51:10.5 -> ( sun_alt - moon_alt ) = 0.278859° (using Standard Refraction model)
2023-Oct-14 18:51:08.5 -> ( sun_alt - moon_alt ) = 0.279013° (using Airless model).
Hope that helps - and fingers crossed that clouds keep away and you get an enjoyable eclipse viewing.
Regards, Geoff Hitchcox, Christchurch, New Zealand - no eclipse for us this time ;-(